Market Declines: What Is Accomplished by Banning Short-Selling? (Federal Reserve Bank of New York)

August 2012

KEYWORDS: Department of the Treasury, Federal Reserve Bank of New York, Federal Reserve Board, Italy, Liquidity, SEC, Securities and Exchange Commission, Short Selling, short selling ban, Spain, stock, TARP, Troubled Asset Relief Program, United States Congress

Authors:

Robert Battalio, Hamid Mehran, and Paul Schultz

Organizations:
  • Federal Reserve Bank of New York

Summary:

In 2008, U.S. regulators banned the short-selling of financial stocks, fearing that the practice was helping to drive the steep drop in stock prices during the crisis. However, a new look at the effects of such restrictions challenges the notion that short sales exacerbate market downturns in this way. The 2008 ban on short sales failed to slow the decline in the price of financial stocks; in fact, prices fell markedly over the two weeks in which the ban was in effect and stabilized once it was lifted. Similarly, following the downgrade of the U.S. sovereign credit rating in 2011—another notable period of market stress—stocks subject to short-selling restrictions performed worse than stocks free of such restraints.

Related Research and Data