The High-Frequency Trading Arms Race: Frequent Batch Auctions as a Market Design Response (AQR Insight Award Winner)

May 2014

KEYWORDS: High-Frequency Trading, HFT, arbitrage, bid-ask spread, exchange speed

Summary:

We argue that the continuous limit order book is a flawed market design and propose that financial exchanges instead use frequent batch auctions: uniform-price sealed-bid double auctions conducted at frequent but discrete time intervals, e.g., every 1 second. Our argument has four parts. First, we use millisecond-level direct-feed data from exchanges to show that the continuous limit order book market design does not really “work” in continuous time: market correlations completely break down at high-frequency time horizons. Second, we show that this correlation breakdown creates frequent technical arbitrage opportunities, available to whomever is fastest, which in turn creates an arms race to exploit such opportunities. Third, we develop a simple new theory model motivated by these empirical facts. The model shows that the arms race is not only socially wasteful – a prisoner’s dilemma built directly into the market design – but moreover that its cost is ultimately borne by investors via wider spreads and thinner markets. Last, we show that frequent batch auctions eliminate the arms race, both because they reduce the value of tiny speed advantages and because they transform competition on speed into competition on price. Consequently, frequent batch auctions lead to narrower spreads, deeper markets, and increased social welfare.

Related Research and Data

• News and Monetary Shocks at a High Frequency: A Simple Approach (International Monetary Fund) September 2014
• Chart of the week: Are widening high yield spreads cause for concern? (J.P. Morgan) July 2014
• Monthly Hedge Fund Trends – July 2014 (Deutsche Bank) July 2014
• Comomentum: Inferring Arbitrage Activity From Return Correlations (AQR Insight Award Winner) May 2014
• European Equity Market Structure Survey (ConvergEx Group LLC) May 2014
• High Frequency Trading and Price Discovery (European Central Bank) November 2013
• Center for the Study of Financial Regulation – Summer 2013 (Center for the Study of Financial Regulation, Mendoza School of Business, University of Notre Dame) Summer 2013
• Hedge Fund Industry Snapshot – May 2013 (Citi Prime Finance) May 2013
• Some insights into the details that matter for high-frequency trading (Eurex) May 2013
• The Rise of Liquid Alternatives & the Changing Dynamics of Alternative Product Manufacturing and Distribution (Citi) May 2013
• Markets Prime Finance Quarterly Webcast (Deutsche Bank) April 2013
• Hedge Fund Industry Snapshot – April 2013 (Citi Prime Finance) April 2013
• A New Look at the Role of Sovereign Credit Default Swaps (International Monetary Fund) April 2013
• Report of the Survey on Hedge Fund Activities of SFC-licensed Managers/Advisers (Hong Kong Securities and Futures Commission) March 2013
• What Do We Know About High-Frequency Trading? (Charles M. Jones, Columbia Business School) March 2013
• Eleventh Annual Alternative Investment Survey (Deutsche Bank) February 2013
• High-Frequency Trading and the Execution Costs of Institutional Investors (Financial Services Authority) January 2013
• Center for the Study of Financial Regulation – Winter 2013 (Center for the Study of Financial Regulation, Mendoza School of Business, University of Notre Dame) Winter 2012
• Monthly Hedge Fund Trends – December 2012 (Deutsche Bank) December 2012
• Financial Transaction Taxes: International Experiences, Issues and Feasibility (Bank of Canada) November 2012
• Center for the Study of Financial Regulation – Fall 2012 (Center for the Study of Financial Regulation, Mendoza School of Business, University of Notre Dame) Fall 2012
• PwC’s; Financial Services Regulatory Practice: How we can help quantitatively driven asset managers (PricewaterhouseCoopers) August 2010
• Center for the Study of Financial Regulation – Spring 2012 (The Center for the Study of Financial Regulation at the University of Notre Dame) Spring 2012
• Portfolio Partnership and Due Diligence (State Street) January 2012
• The Possibilities and Limitations of Algorithmic Trading (Forefactor Inc.) December 2011
• Last Second Idea (Securities Technology Monitor) December 21, 2011
• High-Frequency Trading (Eurex) March 2011
• High Frequency Trading and Volatility (Jonathan Brogaard, University of Washington) October 4, 2011
• High-frequency trading in the foreign exchange market (Bank for International Settlements) September 2011
• High Frequency Trading and The New-Market Makers (VU University Amsterdam) August 14, 2011
• Center for the Study of Financial Regulation – Winter 2011 (Center for the Study of Financial Regulation, Mendoza School of Business, University of Notre Dame) Winter 2011